How to Read a Gumshoe Verification Report: A Field Guide to the Results
Tiles, scores, PASS, WARN, FAIL, NA — your first verification report has a lot on it. Here is what each section means, what to action, and what to file.
Your first Gumshoe verification report returns in a few seconds and contains more information than most supplier due diligence processes produce in an hour. The tile layout is designed to be scanned quickly — but understanding what each result actually represents takes a little more than a scan.
This is a field guide to the report. What each status means, what to action, what to file, and what the overall risk score is actually measuring.
The Status Labels
PASS means the check ran and the supplier cleared this particular register, lookup, or assessment. A PASS is a finding — not a default state.
WARN means the check found something worth noting but not conclusive. Common WARN situations: a recently registered domain (new businesses can be entirely legitimate), a recently registered ABN for a company (not uncommon for new contractors, worth noting for large first invoices), a business name that expired and was recently renewed (a compliance gap, not fraud).
FAIL means the check found a negative result that warrants attention. A FAIL on insolvency indicates the entity or a connected entity is in external administration. A FAIL on banned persons indicates a director is on the ASIC disqualification list. A FAIL on ABN status indicates the ABN is cancelled or has never been active.
NA means the check is not applicable to this entity. NA is informational — it tells you the check ran, assessed the entity type, and determined it does not apply. It is not a problem.
The Two-Round Return
Gumshoe results arrive in two rounds. The first round — fast checks — covers ABR data, ASIC company status, business name registration, and domain and email lookups. These checks are answered with a direct database query or a DNS lookup.
The second round — deep checks — covers cross-referencing against the insolvency gazette, the banned persons register, financial licences, trade licences, adverse records, and charity registration. These involve more complex lookups across larger datasets.
You can read and act on the first-round results while the second round is still running. The overall risk score updates when the full picture is in.
The Risk Score
The overall risk score is a composite across all checks. It is not a simple count of PASS and FAIL results — the weights reflect the severity of each check.
As a practical guide to the score ranges:
- Clean: All or nearly all checks passed. File the result and proceed.
- Low risk: One or two minor WARN results, no FAILs. Note the WARNs and continue with standard payment terms.
- Moderate: Multiple WARNs or one FAIL. Consider a manual review before first payment, or ask the supplier to address the flagged items.
- High: Significant flags present. Recommend manual review, references, or a conditional first engagement before extending terms.
- Critical: Active FAILs on high-weight checks (insolvency, banned persons, cancelled ABN). Consult legal or financial advice before proceeding.
Expanding the Tiles
Each tile is expandable, showing the underlying data that produced the result. For a FAIL or WARN, the expanded view shows what was found.
This expanded data is what belongs in your audit record. If the report is later reviewed in a dispute or fraud investigation, the tile detail shows that the check was substantive — not just that a box was ticked.
What to Do With the Report
A clean report (score below 40, no FAILs): save the PDF or screenshot, note the date and ABN, file it against the supplier record in your AP system. Done.
A report with WARNs: note which checks triggered and why. For most WARNs — short domain age, recent ABN registration, minor business name issues — you are making a judgement call about whether the context explains them. Document that judgement in the supplier file alongside the report.
A report with FAILs: stop and review before processing any payments. Expand the relevant tiles to see the underlying data. If the FAIL is on insolvency or banned persons, seek advice before proceeding. If the FAIL is on ABN status, do not process the invoice until the ABN situation is resolved.
The report takes a few seconds to generate. The decision-making it supports may take longer — but it should be an informed decision, with documented evidence, not a guess based on a supplier's word.
Uncommon Insights
The risk score range of 0-100, with lower scores indicating lower risk, may seem counterintuitive to some users. However, it is essential to note that the risk score is not a linear measure of risk but rather a weighted combination of signals. A single FAIL status may not necessarily result in a high risk score if the other checks return PASS or WARN statuses. Conversely, multiple WARN statuses may contribute to a higher risk score than a single FAIL status, depending on the specific checks and the supplier's overall risk profile.
ASIC's enforcement patterns suggest that the regulator is increasingly focusing on compliance with anti-money laundering and counter-terrorism financing (AML/CTF) obligations. In this context, a FAIL status on the financial licences check may indicate that the supplier is not compliant with AML/CTF requirements, which could lead to significant penalties and reputational damage. CFOs and accountants should carefully review the supplier's AML/CTF compliance and take steps to mitigate any potential risks.
Run a free supplier check
Search by business name, ABN, or ACN. Get a PASS/WARN/FAIL result across key verification signals.
Start verifying →


